redditr/InsuranceAgentpostagentScore: 0
I feel like my agency owner is playing me.
I feel like my agency owner is playing me.
I could use some honest advice from people in the insurance industry.
I work as an LSP at an Allstate agency. My boss hired me after I left bartending, paid for my licensing, and gave me my start in insurance which I’m grateful for. I actually like the industry and want to stay in it long term.
Here’s where I’m confused.
When I started, I was shown a comp plan based on hitting a certain number of items before commission kicked in. Later my boss told me (verbatim):
“I’m changing your base salary so you can start getting paid off every dollar you make.”
The problem is… that never happened.
I’m the only LSP in the office. I:
• make the calls
• quote households
• bind policies
• sometimes even do service work
Last February the agency wrote about $26,000 in premium and I personally produced a little over half (\~$13k).
I have never seen a commission check. Not even $100.
Which confuses me because obviously the agency owner receives commission on the business written.
Now I’m stuck in a weird spot:
• I don’t want to leave because this guy got me into the industry
• I do believe insurance is a long-term career
• but I also feel like I might just be grinding for mailbox money for someone else
I’m still fairly new to insurance so I genuinely don’t know if:
1. This is normal for a new LSP
2. I misunderstood the comp plan
3. Or if I’m actually being underpaid for production
For context I’m putting in the work — recently did 172 dials in a day, quoted 4 households (10 items) etc.
So my question for agency owners and LSPs:
Is it normal to produce business and not see any commission at all?
Or should I start looking at other agencies?
I really want to stay in insurance — I just want to make sure I’m not grinding in the wrong place.
Would appreciate honest feedback.
UPDATE: so I had the talk with my boss. He was right I do make commission off the first dollar. 4% so my 13k I made in February will hit this month. Comp plan is under 30k =4% 31k-35k = 6% 35k - 45k = 8% and 50k+ = 15%
- Post Date
- 3/8/2026, 5:19:35 AM
- Scraped At
- 3/15/2026, 9:25:12 AM
Metadata
{
"score": 0,
"title": "I feel like my agency owner is playing me.",
"subreddit": "InsuranceAgent",
"num_comments": 58,
"scrape_method": "apify_targeted"
}Scrape Run
reddit — completed — 1798 posts collected